Villages, Women, and the Success of Dairy Cooperatives in India: Making Place for Rural Development
Powered By Xquantum

Villages, Women, and the Success of Dairy Cooperatives in India: ...

Chapter 1:  Introduction: Seeking Success, Finding Farmers
Read
image Next

This is a limited free preview of this book. Please buy full access.


useful to understanding the class dimensions of contemporary agrarian politics. Given that all rural classes are sought to be included within these movements, the separate interests of small farmers have not been articulated here. Instead, the needs of relatively large landowners are usually paraded as being consistent with the needs of all sections of rural society. Summarizing the landscape of agricultural social movements in India, Brass (1994) argued that while previous agrarian movements were focused on issues of land redistribution, new farmers' movements have mostly focused on obtaining higher prices for agricultural produce. Contemporary agrarian politics in India can thus be linked to the decline of the Green Revolution, with landed rural segments seeking to maintain the profitability of their enterprises against the encroachments of multinational capitalist interests, while evading the question of whether this aim is sufficient to address the needs of all rural classes. Thus,

from the standpoint of society as a whole, the farmers' movements are essentially conservative movements that seek to reinforce the existing property rights and consolidate a broad-based and diversified rural capitalism where rural industrialization is not left to the large business groups. (Banaji 1994, 239)

Moreover, new farmers' movements have also proved willing to form opportunistic alliances when the possibility of gaining benefits through access to corporate and state power has presented itself. As such,

the new farmers' movements' antagonism towards the state is itself partial and class-specific: while state intervention on the issue of remunerative prices is perceived as desirable and thus actively sought, there is simultaneously an equally strong opposition by the new farmers' movements to the (actual or potential) implementation by the state of legislation enforcing land ceilings and minimum wages. (Brass 1994, 36)

In contrast to this emphasis on the conservative nature of agrarian politics in India, Omvedt (1993) considered farmers' movements as the embodiment of progressive rural orientations, and sought to show that