Observing Society: Meaning, Communication, and Social Systems
Powered By Xquantum

Observing Society: Meaning, Communication, and Social Systems By ...

Chapter 1:  Distinctions: Observation, Meaning, and the Reduction of Complexity
Read
image Next

According to Spencer Brown's innovative “calculus of indications,” observing any form of difference always entails two steps: drawing a two-sided distinction and, in the same operation, selecting or indicating one side or the other.

Although his work received mixed reviews from his own peers, Spencer Brown's impact on the German sociologist Niklas Luhmann was critical. One of the most prominent, creative, and prolific sociologists of the twentieth century, Luhmann acknowledged the method of observing through distinctions as a guiding principle in his scholarship. The pioneer of contemporary social system theory cited no more than a few selected pages from Laws of Form, but Luhmann repeatedly returned to the problem of how an observer draws a distinction to produce a world. For instance, in his book, Art as a Social System, Luhmann wrote,

Since observation depends on distinction, it must dissolve and make invisible the underlying paradox of the unity of the distinguishing activity, it must replace this unity with operatively useful distinctions, it must unfold the paradox—there is no other way of arriving at identities capable of operation.
The first caesura, the first cut into the unmarked state of the world, must be executed, and not just to generate two sides. Rather, the cut must yield an asymmetrical use of these sides, which allows for connecting operations on one side but not on the other. This is how sequences are set in motion that reproduce the problem in the realm of already executed distinctions in such a way that further observations can follow. (2000a:42)

The first cut made by an observer of society divides communication from its environment, from all that is not communication. Society is communication, as we will make clear, and it is the superset that contains all social systems. An observer of a social system identifies unities of sequential communicative operations, operations that successfully establish connectivity, one observation at a time, with the emerging history of society. This technique of observing with reference to a clear distinction